German antitrust authority probes PayPal’s no-surcharge policy

Germany’s competition watchdog has PayPal’s fee rules in its sights. The Federal Cartel Office, known as the Bundeskartellamt, has issued a preliminary assessment saying PayPal’s ban on merchants adding surcharges for its payment option may hinder competition.

The authority also says the practice could violate both German and EU competition law. It is weighing whether PayPal may have to hand back profits earned through the rule, which raises the stakes well beyond a simple clause rewrite.

What the watchdog is objecting to

The setup is fairly simple. Merchants that accept PayPal agree to contractual terms that stop them from charging shoppers extra for choosing PayPal at checkout.